Ice Science is Hot Stuff

One of the most common questions we get is; “Should I use ice or heat?” Despite all the information readily available from “Dr. Google”, people remained confused about what is the best approach. It’s really no wonder that there is still such a divide to what seems to be a straight forward question. Either ice helps or heat helps, right? Well, it depends.

Today, when science is misunderstood and constantly ignored more than professional wrestling, it’s harder than ever to understand what are facts and what are ‘alternative’ facts. Too often, we try to find the facts that best support our own conclusions, instead of starting with the facts and drawing conclusions from them.

ice or heat

What if I told you that the doctor who originally coined the acronym of RICE (rest, ice, compression & elevation) back in 1978, publicly recanted this antiquated approach? In 2013, Dr. Gabe Mirkin completed a study where 22 scientific articles found almost no evidence that ice and compression hastened healing over the use of compression alone, although ice plus exercise may marginally help to heal ankle sprains (The American Journal of Sports Medicine, January 2004;32(1):251-261). Yet, you talk to most professionals or roll up on any athletic field, you will see the approach of RICE as the go to protocol when treating acute injuries.

“When you damage tissue through trauma or develop muscle soreness by exercising very intensely, you heal by using your immunity, the same biological mechanisms that you use to kill germs. This is called inflammation. When germs get into your body, your immunity sends cells and proteins into the infected area to kill the germs. When muscles and other tissues are damaged, your immunity sends the same inflammatory cells to the damaged tissue to promote healing. The response to both infection and tissue damage is the same. Inflammatory cells rush to injured tissue to start the healing process (Journal of American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons, Vol 7, No 5, 1999). The inflammatory cells called macrophages release a hormone called Insulin-like growth Factor (IGF-1) into the damaged tissues, which helps muscles and other injured parts to heal. However, applying ice to reduce swelling actually delays healing by preventing the body from releasing IGF-1.”

Ultimately, what I think most people fail to understand is why immediately grabbing some ice and popping a few anti-inflammatory pills is exactly what you DON’T want to do when you are injured.

INFLAMMATION IS GOOD!
It is our bodies primary defense against injury and infection. Reaching for ice and/or ant-inflammatory pills is the equivalent of wrangling up your neighbors to prevent the fire department from saving your home when it’s on fire.

Yes, TOO much inflammation can be bad. Yes, inflammation DOES indeed cause pain. However, without inflammation, your body would never heal from infection or disease. Therefore, you should consult a physician who is both aware of the science as well as your condition so they can properly administer sound treatment approach.

I wish the answer to the original question was as simple as “ice for x” and “heat for y”, but alas, nothing is straight forward when it comes to the “three I’s”; Injury, Infection & Individuals. To properly answer this question, there are a multitude of factors that must first be considered. In the meantime, I would strongly encourage you to read an article written by one of my colleagues which goes into great depths on this subject.

Please Hold the R.I.C.E.

By Drew Freedman | December 3, 2022

Please Hold the R.I.C.E. I have been in the rehabilitation field since 1992. Since the very beginning I was always told that when treating an acute injury you should follow the age old acronym of R.I.C.E. or Rest, Ice, Compression and Elevation. The concept was originally introduced by one of the most respected names in…

Have a Brettzel!

By Drew Freedman | November 30, 2022

Have a Brettzel! In the world of flexibility and stretching, there are a bevy of stretches that have likely been shown to you over the years. It’s hard to remember them if you don’t consistently do them and the ones you likely DO recall are the ones that are probably easiest for YOU to perform.…

Take 5: A Stress Break

By Drew Freedman | November 4, 2022

Take 5: A Stress Break I will be the first in line to inform you of the benefits of a 60 minute massage treatment. However, what if your massage is not scheduled for another week or worse, not even scheduled? Well, as a firm believer and trumpeter of self-care, here is a pretty neat trick…

Is it a Muscle Cramp or Muscle Strain?

By Drew Freedman | November 4, 2022

Is it a Muscle Cramp or Muscle Strain? Last week when my daughter walked in from cheerleading practice, I noticed her limping. When I asked her why she was limping, she went on to explain what I often hear and have seen from my athletes.  Having been fortunate to evade serious injuries until this point…

Work From Home Hacks!

By Drew Freedman | April 13, 2020

With so many of you experiencing a new work environment, you are probably starting to notice that many of the chronic aches and pains you had experienced in the past at work on a daily basis, have seemingly disappeared. In their place however, are a new set of sensations we are experiencing due to such…

How to Fold a Fitted Sheet

By Drew Freedman | February 14, 2020

Have a ‘sheety’ Valentine’s Day! Today is Valentine’s Day, otherwise known to most as a #greetingcardholiday.  As I walked out of CVS this morning, I laughed at the people who were fighting for position in the greeting card aisle.  Valentine’s Day is about showing love for someone in your life, not elbowing strangers while cursing…

Happiness is Contagious

By Drew Freedman | December 10, 2019

Happiness is Contagious Maybe mom was right. Research suggests that surrounding yourself with friends and family who are happy can actually increase your own happiness. Scientists at Harvard University and the University of California, San Diego, found that emotions, particularly happiness, have a viral effect in how they spread from one person to another. For…

De-stressing the Commute

By Drew Freedman | October 31, 2019

De-stressing the Commute Turning Road Rage into Road Sage The average American commuter spends an hour a day driving to and from work. During this stressful, stop-and-go time, it’s likely that blood pressure increases, adrenaline begins pumping, and muscles constrict and tighten. By the time you get home, you’re wiped out and grumpy, and you…

What’s the Scoop on your Poop?

By Drew Freedman | October 31, 2019

What’s the Scoop on your Poop? Being the father of two girls, I know I have my work cut out for me. I have come to accept that there are lessons that I can teach my children and there are others lessons they will simply have to learn through personal experience. One of the lessons…

Halloween Hacked!

By Drew Freedman | October 2, 2019

Halloween Hacked Check out these simple hacks! Who among us doesn’t love Halloween. If I am being honest, it used to be me!  You see, I typically found myself in trouble around this time of year when I was in grammar school.  Let’s just say that I wasn’t always motivated to do what was asked…